the pirate story
August 1st, 2006 by francesca-lois
Last weekend, while I was in Davao, my family and I watched The Pirates of the Caribbean: Dead Man’s Chest as a family bonding activity. I was seated with my two brothers Arthur (who is 22 years old) and Abdul (who will be turning 20 this year) while my youngest brother Alec (5 years old turning 6 this year) was seated between my parents in the row in front of us. As was usually the case when neither the kuyas’s nor I was seated with Alec, I began to worry. I believed that movie viewing for kids his age should be properly guided and I don’t exactly trust my mom to do that because usually she doesn’t understand the context (especially fantasy or the like genre i.e. X-Men, the Lod of the Rings, etc.) either. I think this is because of a bit of generation gap and my mom doesn’t read stuff like that. However, as my dad was there too, I relaxed a little and proceeded to enjoy the movie.
On our way home, the expected happened. My mom complained that she didn’t understand the movie much.
Reasons:
“Was it because I didn’t watch the first movie?”, she asked.
“No, it’s really a bit hard to understand because, Jack Sparrow likes to confuse his men with his logic to a point that he ends up confusing the audience as well” according to Papa. He was referring to Johnny Depp’s character’s penchance for long winded reasoning that he (Depp/Sparrow) contradicts as soon as his men asks questions to clarify.
“Mama, because it’s in Chinese.” quips Alec.
Obviously, the last statement blew me away. It confirmed my worse fears. My brother didn’t understand anything. He probably was overwhelmed by the action scenes and the visual effects that he didn’t realize that the Pirate was speaking English. He mistook the Pirate’s heavily accented English as being another language (well, sometimes it almost is anyway, so I can’t really blame him). I wondered what sort of reasoning processes he must have gone through to get to that conclusion. Or maybe for kids it doesn’t really matter. All that’s important is his own interpretation of the movie and whether or not he enjoyed it.
I still maintain that kids should be supervised by a knowledgeable adult in watching movies though. So that somebody can explain the story and it’s context whether or not the kid asks questions.

